Monday, December 26, 2022

Why I will continue to slam AL TV stations


From: Rob Shattuck <rdshatt@aol.com>
To: comments@abc3340.com, programming@abc3340.com, Susana.Schuler@hearst.com, blong@hearst.com, wcromwell@cbs42.com, rmartin@cbs42.com, collin.gaston@wbrc.com, jama.killingsworth@waff.com, julie@waff.com, paul.caron@whnt.com, mwright@waaytv.com, sgallien@waaytv.com, eric.duncan@fox10tv.com, Randy.Merrow@fox10tv.com, news@mynbc15.com, dsingleton@mynbc15.com, PAlbrecht@wkrg.com, clombard@wkrg.com, robby.thomas@wtvy.com, stephen.crews@wtvy.com, TCole@wdhn.com, RWare@wdhn.com, mbunting@wsfa.com, sduff@wsfa.com, ghalbrooks@alabamanews.net, jrainey@alabamanews.net, sdiorio@wvua23.com, knorred@wvua23.com,emileigh.forrester@whnt.com, emily.moessner@whnt.com, greg.screws@whnt.com,hbaker@waff.com, sean.dowling@waff.com, matthew.king@waff.com
dshaffer@waaytv.com, nwilliams@waaytv.com, mwaxel@waaytv.comSent: Mon, Dec 26, 2022 6:36 pm
Subject: Why I will continue to slam Alabama TV stations
https://al6thcongdist-ihaveuntiljan13.blogspot.com/2022/12/why-i-will-continue-to-slam-al-tv.html

[12/31.My page view counter indicates that this webpage received 60 page views shortly after the foregoing email was sent. I have received no email communication back.]

Saturday, December 24, 2022

#GunsForSelfDefenseOnly (cont'd)

Email "What is wrong with the mantra #GunsForSelfDefenseOnly?"
From: Rob Shattuck <rdshatt@aol.com>
To: gvs@jh.edu, cgvs@jhu.edu, contactus@protectourschools.com, cbarry@cornell.edu,
jpeterson68@hamline.edu, preventgunviolencefl@gmail.com, gail@bawnfl.org, info@giffords.org, melie@uabmc.edu, mslay@uab.edu, eeaton@uab.edu,
mary.bernstein@uconn.edu, jennifer.dineen@uconn.edu, kerri.raissian@uconn.edu, mstankiewicz@bradyunited.org, sona.dimidjian@colorado.edu, beverly.kingston@colorado.edu, jonathanm@bebta.org, donna.mejia@colorado.edu, Emergency.Medicine@cuanschutz.edu, StartClinic@UCDenver.edu, mdoucet3@jhu.edu, alabama@momschapterleaders.org
Sent: Fri, Dec 23, 2022 4:55 pm
Subject: What is wrong with the mantra #GunsForSelfDefenseOnly?
I am sorry to bother you gun violence reduction proponents again.
Can someone please tell me what is wrong with the mantra #GunsForSelfDefenseOnly, and why that mantra is not at this time excellent for shaping, advocating for, and defending in the courts, most, if not all, common sense solutions for reducing gun violence?
Compared to #GunsForSelfDefenseOnly being good across the range of common sense solutions for reducing gun violence, advocacy terminology like "banning weapons of war" is of limited applicability in the universe of gun violence reduction ideas.
When gun rights advocates scream about "taking away Second Amendment rights of law abiding citizens," many Americans, I believe, tune out of the discussion, whereas debating about #GunsForSelfDefenseOnly I think can get a lot of engagement of average Americans.[asterisk]
If you think I am wrong here, please tell me why.
If you agree with what I am saying here, it would be great to hear that from you.
Thank you.
Rob Shattuck

[asterisk] It seems to me the recent Rhode Island high capacity gun magazine ban case (Judge upholds Rhode Island's high-capacity gun magazine ban. Here's what it means) shows the merits of the mantra of #GunsForSelfDefenseOnly.
The below are quoted from the foregoing article and are either exact quotations of what Judge McConnell said in the case or characterize what the Judge said:
"Consistent with its obligation to protect public safety, but consonant with its fealty to the Constitution, the Rhode Island General Assembly has responded with, among other firearms regulations, the [large capacity magazine] Ban."
The Second Amendment protects the right to people to "keep and bear arms," and at its core the right to self-defense, McConnell observed.
The ban was a reasonable and measured approach to restricting large-capacity magazines, which in practice easily convert handguns into semi-automatic weapons capable of rapid fire, he said.
He accepted the opinion of an expert for the state that throughout history "high capacity firearms ... were understood to be weapons of war or anti-insurrection, not weapons of individual self defense."
Where the Judge refers to "fealty to the Constitution," the touchstone for that is that SCOTUS has pronounced that there is a constitutional right of individuals to own and carry guns in public for self-defense.
That right does not exist in a vacuum, and there is also a governmental "obligation to protect public safety."
Those two things (the "right to self-defense" and "protect[ing] public safety") frame and will frame just about every gun control case.
I think the public can understand those two things (the "right to self-defense" and "protect[ing] public safety"), and the public understanding those two things will allow the public to better evaluate what they hear from the two sides about gun control cases.


Email to Baltimore City Council members
From: Rob Shattuck <rdshatt@aol.com>
To: CouncilPresident@baltimorecity.gov, Zeke.Cohen@baltimorecity.gov, Danielle.McCray@baltimorecity.gov, Ryan.Dorsey@baltimorecity.gov, Mark.Conway@baltimorecity.gov, Isaac.Schleifer@baltimorecity.gov, Sharon.Middleton@baltimorecity.gov, James.Torrence@baltimorecity.gov, Kristerfer.Burnett@baltimorecity.gov, John.Bullock@baltimorecity.gov, Phylicia.Porter@baltimorecity.gov, Eric.Costello@baltimorecity.gov, Robert.Stokes@baltimorecity.gov, Antonio.Glover@baltimorecity.gov, Odette.Ramos@baltimorecity.gov,
Cc: clinton.woods@birminghamal.gov, hunter.williams@birminghamal.gov, valerie.abbott@birminghamal.gov, jonathan.moore2@birminghamal.gov, Darrell.OQuinn@birminghamal.gov, crystal.smitherman@birminghamal.gov, wardine.alexander@birminghamal.gov, carol.clarke@birminghamal.gov, latonya.tate@birminghamal.gov, tysons@jccal.org, stephensj@jccal.org, KnightJoe@jccal.org, ammonss@jccal.org, scalesl@jccal.org,
Sent: Fri, Feb 3, 2023 7:02 pm
Subject: #GunsForSelfDefenseOnly in Alabama
Dear Baltimore City Council Members:
In Alabama I am pushing the mantra #GunsForSelfDefenseOnly for use in shaping, advocating for, and defending in the courts, common sense solutions for reducing gun violence. This has included emailing numerous Alabama city councilors and county commissioners. See https://al6thcongdist-ihaveuntiljan13.blogspot.com/2022/12/mayors-letter-to-schumer-mcconnell-re.html.
In Alabama, the GOP controlled state legislature has statewide control over gun laws and gun regulation and it is opposed to common sense solutions for reducing gun violence. Alabama local governments are powerless as to guns in the face of the GOP state legislature control.
Maryland is auspicious for the mantra #GunsForSelfDefenseOnly getting used in shaping, advocating for, and defending in the courts, common sense solutions for reducing gun violence in Maryland.
I hope you will consider the same.
For what it is worth, I am copying my Birmingham City Councilors and Jefferson County (AL) county commissioners on this email.
Thank you.
Sincerely,
Rob Shattuck
Mountain Brook, AL

Email to Maryland constitutional law professors
From: Rob Shattuck <rdshatt@aol.com>
To: rboldt@law.umaryland.edu <rboldt@law.umaryland.edu>; mmeyerson@ubalt.edu <mmeyerson@ubalt.edu>; higginbotham@ubalt.edu <higginbotham@ubalt.edu>; mstearns@law.umaryland.edu <mstearns@law.umaryland.edu>
Cc: dmsmolin@samford.edu <dmsmolin@samford.edu>; phorwitz@law.ua.edu <phorwitz@law.ua.edu>; mbrandon@law.ua.edu <mbrandon@law.ua.edu>; aolree@faulkner.edu <aolree@faulkner.edu>; fvars@law.ua.edu <fvars@law.ua.edu>; jvance@law.ua.edu <jvance@law.ua.edu>
Sent: Tue, Feb 14, 2023 10:25 am
Subject: #GunsForSelfDefenseOnly in Alabama
Dear Professors Boldt, Meyerson, Higginbotham and Stearns:
I sent the below email to the Baltimore City Council members in connection with the January 29th mass shooting in Baltimore that is reported at 2-year-old among 4 people shot in Baltimore - ABC7 New York (abc7ny.com).
My email urged the use of the mantra #GunsForSelfDefenseOnly for shaping, advocating for, and defending in the courts, common sense solutions for reducing gun violence.
Such mantra needs supporting opinion about what the Second Amendment protects and does not protect.
In Alabama, I have solicited such opinion from Alabama constitutional law professors (whom I have copied on this email).
I am sending this email to you as Maryland constitutional law professors for whatever assistance you may be moved to provide, relative to my urging the Baltimore City Council to take up the mantra #GunsForSelfDefenseOnly for reducing gun violence in Maryland.
Thank you for your attention to this email.
Sincerely,
Rob Shattuck
Mountain Brook, AL

Email to Michigan constitutional law professors
From: Rob Shattuck <rdshatt@aol.com>
To: michael.lawrence@law.msu.edu, eboddie@umich.edu, caminker@umich.edu, samerman@umich.edu, rdfrdman@umich.edu, dhalber@umich.edu, dherzog@umich.edu
Cc:dmsmolin@samford.edu, phorwitz@law.ua.edu, mbrandon@law.ua.edu , aolree@faulkner.edu, fvars@law.ua.edu, jvance@law.ua.edu, rboldt@law.umaryland.edu, mmeyerson@ubalt.edu, higginbotham@ubalt.edu, mstearns@law.umaryland.edu,
Sent: Fri, Feb 24, 2023 4:46 am
Subject: Michigan law professor support for Michigan gun control
Dear Professors Lawrence, Boddie, Caminker, Erman, Friedman, Halberstam and Herzog:
I am a retired lawyer in Alabama.
The history-and-tradition framework for gun cases that the United States Supreme Court enunciated in the Bruen case has made gun control much more difficult to achieve in the United States. Supreme Court ruling creates turmoil over gun laws in lower courts | PBS NewsHour; Tracking the Effects of the Supreme Court’s Gun Ruling
I have come up with the mantra #GunsForSelfDefenseOnly to guide the shaping, advocating for, and defending in the courts, common sense gun solutions.
I have solicited constitutional law professors in Alabama and elsewhere to consider the constitutional viability of such mantra for pursuing gun control. See https://al6thcongdist-ihaveuntiljan13.blogspot.com/2022/12/gunsforselfdefenseonly-contd.html and
https://al6thcongdist-ihaveuntiljan13.blogspot.com/2022/10/pressuring-gov-ivey-for-leadership-on.html.
I hope one or more constitutional law professors in Michigan will take this up.
The persons I have copied on this email are Alabama and Maryland constitutional law professors to whom I have previously sent emails.
Thank you.
Rob Shattuck
Mountain Brook, AL

Wednesday, December 21, 2022

Why our governance sucks

I. AL.COM
[Below is copied and pasted from https://link.al.com/join/6fp/signup.]

Newsletter signup

Select the newsletters you'd like to receive and enter your email address below.

 Weekly, Tuesday

Columnist John Archibald uncovers things you don’t know and need to know about corruption and fairness in Alabama, with humor and heart.

 Weekly, Thursday

Columnist Roy S. Johnson's weekly newsletter is a place for everything, from thoughtful talk to trash talk. You'll leave feeling better than when you arrived.

 Weekly, Wednesday

If you’re fed up with the state of Alabama, don’t lose hope. Sign up for Kyle Whitmire’s weekly newsletter.

 Pop-up (limited duration)

A newsletter highlighting our series on gun violence in Birmingham, produced in partnership with the Birmingham Times.

 Weekly

A five-week series from the Ed Lab team to help you and your family navigate a new school year.

 Weekdays

The latest headlines about what’s happening across Alabama

 As news breaks

Receive email notifications when big stories break.

 Weekly, Wednesday

Expanding conversations and offering solutions for issues affecting Alabama schools

 Weekly, Thursday

College Football with John Talty provides weekly insight, analysis, opinion and unique information for fans who genuinely want to know what is happening behind the scenes around the SEC.


II. Other


 As news stories publish

Get the latest from columnist Kyle Whitmire as he explores how 150 years of whitewashed






Tuesday, December 20, 2022

Miami New Times

Saturday, December 17, 2022

Public safety threat of 2nd Amendment extremists

Wednesday, December 14, 2022

Can Leigh Hulsey lessen my despair in Alabama?

Monday, December 12, 2022

Mayors' letter to Schumer & McConnell re assault weapons ban

[The letter, which I have copied and pasted below, is at https://www.politico.com/f/?id=00000184-e0e1-da2c-a3af-fbe7fccc0000&nname=playbook&nid=0000014f-1646-d88f-a1cf-5f46b7bd0000&nrid=00000163-4f8a-db83-a167-4faf45b60000&nlid=630318]

December 5, 2022
The Honorable Charles Schumer Democratic Leader United States Senate Washington, DC 20510
The Honorable Mitch McConnell Republican Leader United States Senate Washington, DC 20510
Dear Leader Schumer and Leader McConnell:
As mayors of cities that have had mass shootings this year, we write to urge the Senate to pass during the lame duck session gun safety legislation that has passed the House and is currently pending in the Senate. We can tell you firsthand of the devastating impact these shootings have had on our residents and on our cities. While we will never recover from them completely, we must try to prevent them from happening in other cities in the future.
S.736, the Assault Weapons Ban, would ban the sale, import, manufacture or transfer of certain semi-automatic weapons, bump fire stocks, and high-capacity feeding devices. It would exempt from the ban all assault weapons lawfully possessed on the date of enactment and would not apply to antique firearms, manually operated firearms, and more than 2,000 specified models of hunting and sporting firearms. It does not in any way infringe on Second Amendment rights. Its companion bill, H.R. 1808, passed the House of Representatives on July 29.
S.529, the Background Check Expansion Act would close serious loopholes in the background check system by requiring all firearm purchases—both handguns and long guns—to undergo a NICS background check, help prevent dangerous individuals from circumventing the laws on the books and obtaining deadly weapons, reduce firearms trafficking by prohibiting unlicensed transfers through unregulated secondary sales, and aid law enforcement’s ability to trace crime guns, which depends on licensed gun dealers’ sales records. It’s companion bill, H.R. 8 passed the House on March 11, 2021.
Congress came together this summer to pass the Bipartisan Safer Communities Act, and both of these bills passed the House with bipartisan support. More than 90 percent of Americans support expanding background checks. Two-thirds support a ban on assault weapons.
How much more death and destruction must our residents and our communities endure before the Senate acts? The time to pass the Assault Weapons Ban and the Background Check Expansion Act is now.
Sincerely,
Randall Woodfin Mayor of Birmingham, AL Steven Reed Mayor of Montgomery, AL Walter Maddox Mayor of Tuscaloosa, AL Frank D. Scott Jr. Mayor of Little Rock, AR Kate Gallego Mayor of Phoenix, AZ Jesse Arreguin Mayor of Berkeley, CA Lily Mei Mayor of Fremont, CA Jerry Dyer Mayor of Fresno, CA Eric Garcetti Mayor of Los Angeles, CA Lucas Ramirez Mayor of Mountain View, CA Darrell Steinberg Mayor of Sacramento, CA London N. Breed Mayor of San Francisco, CA Sam Liccardo Mayor of San Jose, CA Sue Himmelrich Mayor of Santa Monica, CA Lauren Meister Mayor of West Hollywood, CA Michael B. Hancock Mayor of Denver, CO Buddy Dyer Mayor of Orlando, FL Jane Castor Mayor of Tampa, FL Keith A. James Mayor of West Palm Beach, FL Andre Dickens Mayor of Atlanta, GA Hardie Davis Jr. Mayor of Augusta, GA Van R. Johnson II Mayor of Savannah, GA Lori E. Lightfoot Mayor of Chicago, IL Nancy Rodkin Rotering Mayor of Highland Park, IL Rita Ali Mayor of Peoria, IL Thomas P. McNamara Mayor of Rockford, IL James Brainard Mayor of Carmel, IN Jerome A. Prince Mayor of Gary, IN Joseph 'Joe' H. Hogsett Mayor of Indianapolis, IN Greg Fischer Mayor of Louisville, KY Sharon Weston Broome Mayor of Baton Rouge, LA Brandon M Scott Mayor of Baltimore, MD Marcus Muhammad Mayor of Benton Harbor, MI Andy Schor Mayor of Lansing, MI Emily Larson Mayor of Duluth, MN Jacob Frey Mayor of Minneapolis, MN Barbara Buffaloe Mayor of Columbia, MO Quinton Lucas Mayor of Kansas City, MO Tishaura O. Jones Mayor of St. Louis, MO Chokwe Antar Lumumba Esq. Mayor of Jackson, MS Esther E. Manheimer Mayor of Asheville, NC Elaine O'Neal Mayor of Durham, NC Nancy Vaughan Mayor of Greensboro, NC James Allen Joines Mayor of Winston-Salem, NC Tim Keller Mayor of Albuquerque, NM Alan Webber Mayor of Santa Fe, NM Debra March Mayor of Henderson, NV Kathy M. Sheehan Mayor of Albany, NY Byron W. Brown Mayor of Buffalo, NY Waylyn Hobbs Jr. Mayor of Hempstead, NY Eric L. Adams Mayor of New York, NY Malik Evans Mayor of Rochester, NY Aftab Pureval Mayor of Cincinnati, OH Justin Bibb Mayor of Cleveland, OH Andrew J. Ginther Jeffrey J. Mims Jr. Mayor of Dayton, OH Ted Wheeler Mayor of Portland, OR Jim Kenney Mayor of Philadelphia, PA Ed Gainey Mayor of Pittsburgh, PA John J. Tecklenburg Mayor of Charleston, SC Tim Kelly Mayor of Chattanooga, TN Indya Kincannon Mayor of Knoxville, TN Steve Adler Mayor of Austin, TX Ron Nirenberg Mayor of San Antonio, TX Michelle Davis-Younger Kenneth Cooper Alexander Mayor of Norfolk, VA Levar Stoney Mayor of Richmond, VA Bruce Harrell Mayor of Seattle, WA Victoria Woodards Mayor of Tacoma, WA John Martin Antaramian Mayor of Kenosha, WI Satya Rhodes-Conway Mayor of Madison, WI Cavalier Johnson Mayor of Milwaukee, WI Cory Mason Mayor of Racine, WI Tom Cochran CEO and Executive Director Mayor of Columbus, OH Mayor of Manassas, VA

Email to Mayors Woodfin, Reed and Maddox
From: Rob Shattuck <rdshatt@aol.com>
To: alice.williams@birminghamal.gov <alice.williams@birminghamal.gov>; mayor@montgomeryal.gov <mayor@montgomeryal.gov>; MAYOR@TUSCALOOSA.COM <MAYOR@TUSCALOOSA.COM>
Cc: cclinton.woods@birminghamal.gov, hunter.williams@birminghamal.gov, valerie.abbott@birminghamal.gov, jonathan.moore2@birminghamal.gov, Darrell.OQuinn@birminghamal.gov, crystal.smitherman@birminghamal.gov, wardine.alexander@birminghamal.gov, carol.clarke@birminghamal.gov, latonya.tate@birminghamal.gov, tysons@jccal.org, stephensj@jccal.org, KnightJoe@jccal.org, ammonss@jccal.org, scalesl@jccal.org, MWILSON@TUSCALOOSA.COM, RHOWARD@TUSCALOOSA.COM, NCROW@TUSCALOOSA.COM, LBUSBY@TUSCALOOSA.COM, KTYNER@TUSCALOOSA.COM, JFAILE@TUSCALOOSA.COM, CLANIER@TUSCALOOSA.COM, district1@tuscco.com, district2@tuscco.com, district3@tuscco.com, district4@tuscco.com, cjinright@montgomeryal.gov, cccalhoun@montgomeryal.gov, egrimes@montgomeryal.gov, blyons@montgomeryal.gov, mtjohnson@montgomeryal.gov, agraham@montgomeryal.gov, cmcinnis@montgomeryal.gov, gpruitt@montgomeryal.gov, danharris@mc-ala.org, carmenmoore-zeigler@mc-ala.org, rondawalker@mc-ala.org, isaiahsankey@mc-ala.org, dougsingleton@mc-ala.org,
Sent: Wed, Dec 14, 2022 8:31 am
Subject: Your mayors' letter to Leaders Schumer & McConnell re assault weapons ban
Dear Birmingham Mayor Woodfin, Montgomery Mayor Reed and Tuscaloosa Mayor Maddox:
You are among 70 U.S mayors who signed a letter to U.S. Senate Leaders Schumer and McConnell, urging passage of an assault weapons ban. Your letter can be found here.
The letter says, "[The Assault Weapons Ban] does not in any way infringe on Second Amendment rights."
Second Amendment extremists will disagree, and they should be met head on.
I think the mantra #GunsForSelfDefenseOnly would be helpful in meeting the Second Amendment extremists head on.
Earlier this month, the Brady United Against Gun Violence organization published in Roll Call an open letter to the United States Senate, signed by 50 healthcare professionals — including surgeons, pediatricians, emergency medicine doctors, and more — imploring the U.S. Senate to save lives by passing an assault weapons ban. That letter can be found at https://www.bradyunited.org/act/thisisourlane#openletter.
I have emailed to the Brady legal team urging that, to defeat Second Amendment extremists, all advocacy for common sense gun solutions, such as banning assault weapons, should be bolted to the mantra #GunsForSelfDefenseOnly. My email, and other material, can be found at https://al6thcongdist-ihaveuntiljan13.blogspot.com/2022/12/brady-letter-to-us-senate-re-assault.html.
I hope you, and Birmingham, Montgomery and Tuscaloosa city councilors and county commissioners, will consider whether the mantra #GunsForSelfDefenseOnly should be used at this time in shaping, advocating for, and defending in the courts, common sense solutions for reducing gun violence.
Thank you for your attention to this email.
Sincerely,
Rob Shattuck
Mountain Brook

Email to Alabama law enforcement, chambers of commerce and other interested parties
From: Rob Shattuck <rdshatt@aol.com>
To: logginsj@mtnbrook.org, drary@vhal.org, dalbert@montgomeryal.gov, canderson@auburnalabama.org, Bill.Partridge@OxfordAL.gov, shealey@opelika-al.gov, PoliceChief@HuntsvilleAL.gov, government.relations@alea.gov, alsheriffs@aol.com, aacop@aacop.com, pcheatwood@pelhamalabama.gov, jwiggins@irondalepolice.org, crigney@alabasterpolice.org, police@hooveralabama.gov, jlittleton@cityofmontevallo.com, cmorris@cityofpellcity.net, bpdsuggestions@birminghamal.gov, dcole@bcatoday.org, ejerkins@birminghambusinessalliance.com, director@homewoodchamber.org, chamber@vestaviahills.org, rfigh@montgomerychamber.com, chamberinfo@shelbychamber.net, pelhamchamberofcommerce@gmail.com, sandra@leedsareachamber.com, nhewston@mobilechamber.com, jim@westalabamachamber.com, alabama@momschapterleaders.org, jeffw@uab.edu, melie@uabmc.edu, mslay@uab.edu, eeaton@uab.edu, newhopebirmingham@gmail.com, pastortb@nrschurch.org, gmallisham@bcri.org, onoyemi@fiaal.org, fbcensley@gmail.com, dgreen@mtcfc.org, minister@uucbham.org, officestaff@faithchapel.net, katy@churchofthehighlands.com, ashfaq.taufique@bisweb.org, alabama@momschapterleaders.org, danaellis865@gmail.com,
Sent: Sun, Dec 18, 2022 8:57 am
Subject: Way forward to reduce gun violence is to tout #GunsForSelfDefenseOnly
Dear Alabama law enforcement, chambers of commerce and other interested parties:
Earlier this month, Birmingham Mayor Woodfin, Montgomery Mayor Reed and Tuscaloosa Mayor Maddox were among 70 U.S. mayors who signed a letter to Senate Leaders Schumer and McConnell, urging passage of the Assault Weapons Ban and the Background Check Expansion Act. Their letter can be found here.
On Wednesday, I sent the below email to Mayors Woodfin, Reed and Maddox (which I copied to Birmingham, Montgomery and Tuscaloosa city councilors and county commissioners), urging that the mantra #GunsForSelfDefenseOnly be used at this time in shaping, advocating for, and defending in the courts, common sense solutions for reducing gun violence.
I hope your desires for gun violence reduction in Alabama will lead you to think about whether the way forward for reducing gun violence is to use the mantra #GunsForSelfDefenseOnly in shaping, advocating for, and defending in the courts, common sense solutions for reducing gun violence.
If you think that is the case, I hope you will communicate the same to Gov. Ivey, AG Marshall, your Alabama members of Congress, your state legislators in Montgomery, and your local Alabama mayors, city councilors and county commissioners.
Thank you for your attention to this email.
Sincerely,
Rob Shattuck
Mountain Brook
[referenced email to  Mayors Woodfin, Reed and Maddox is above and not duplicated here]

Saturday, December 10, 2022

What will reduce gun violence?


Emails to Faith in Action Birmingham Peacemakers 
From: Rob Shattuck <rdshatt@aol.com>
To: onoyemi@fiaal.org <onoyemi@fiaal.org>; jaigregory@fiaal.org <jaigregory@fiaal.org>
Cc: newhopebirmingham@gmail.com, pastortb@nrschurch.org , gmallisham@bcri.org, onoyemi@fiaal.org, fbcensley@gmail.com, dgreen@mtcfc.org, minister@uucbham.org, officestaff@faithchapel.net, katy@churchofthehighlands.com, ashfaq.taufique@bisweb.org, alabama@momschapterleaders.org, danaellis865@gmail.com ; clinton.woods@birminghamal.gov, hunter.williams@birminghamal.gov, valerie.abbott@birminghamal.gov, jonathan.moore2@birminghamal.gov, Darrell.OQuinn@birminghamal.gov, crystal.smitherman@birminghamal.gov, wardine.alexander@birminghamal.gov, carol.clarke@birminghamal.gov, latonya.tate@birminghamal.gov, tysons@jccal.org, stephensj@jccal.org, KnightJoe@jccal.org, ammonss@jccal.org, scalesl@jccal.org, marie.sutton@birminghamal.gov, rick.journey@birminghamal.gov
Sent: Sat, Dec 10, 2022 8:02 am
Subject: Re: Dec. 10th Car Caravan Processional and Life Celebration Event
Good morning, Onoyemi.
Whenever I can meet with Faith in Action Birmingham Peacemakers and/or the Hub team, that will be great.
I am currently compiling at http://al6thcongdist-ihaveuntiljan13.blogspot.com/2022/12/what-will-reduce-gun-violence.html anyone's thoughts about what will reduce gun violence.
If today's Car Caravan Processional and Life Celebration Event generate expression of things that should be done in Birmingham to reduce gun violence, please pass them along to me and I will post the same at the foregoing link.I hope everyone has a great day today.
Sincerely,
Rob Shattuck
On Thu, Dec 8, 2022 at 8:09 AM Rob Shattuck <rdshatt@aol.com> wrote:
Good morning, Onoyemi.
I hope progress is being made to set up a meeting.
I am particularly interested in whether Faith in Action Birmingham Peacemakers would like to take up the mantra of #GunsForSelfDefenseOnly. Please see how I am pushing this mantra as indicated at .https://al6thcongdist-ihaveuntiljan13.blogspot.com/2022/11/gunsforselfdefenseonly.html.
I continue ready and available for meeting.
Sincerely,
Rob Shattuck
-----Original Message-----
From: Rob Shattuck <rdshatt@aol.com>
To: onoyemi@fiaal.org <onoyemi@fiaal.org>
Sent: Thu, Dec 1, 2022 7:14 am
Subject: Re: Dec. 10th Car Caravan Processional and Life Celebration Event
Thank you, Onoyemi.
Yes, I would be very open to meeting to discuss how my personal interest might align with your leaders' efforts to strengthen this conversation in Alabama.
I am retired and am flexible as to when and where I can meet.
Please suggest a time and place.
Rob Shattuck
-----Original Message-----
On Thu, Nov 24, 2022 at 5:49 AM Rob Shattuck <rdshatt@aol.com> wrote:
Dear Pastor Clarke, Pastor Beavers, and Ms.Mallisham,
In connection with the above Faith in Action Birmingham Peacemakers' events honoring this year's victims of gun violence, I am interested in learning more about the efforts of Faith in Action Birmingham Peacemakers to reduce gun violence in Birmingham and whether I can contribute to the efforts.
I am purveying the "Declaration of public officials for gun violence prevention" that is set out at https://al6thcongdist-ihaveuntiljan13.blogspot.com/2022/09/declaration-of-public-officials-for-gun.html, and I am trying to instigate pressuring of Gov. Ivey as indicated in https://al6thcongdist-ihaveuntiljan13.blogspot.com/2022/10/pressuring-gov-ivey-for-leadership-on.html.
Is what I am doing susceptible of being availed of in any way by Faith in Action Birmingham Peacemakers in their efforts to reduce gun violence in Birmingham?
Thank you for your attention to this email.
Sincerely,
Rob Shattuck
Mountain Brook, AL


11/27 Email "What have AL business chambers done in 2022 against gun violence?"
From: Rob Shattuck <rdshatt@aol.com>
To: dcole@bcatoday.org, ejerkins@birminghambusinessalliance.com, director@homewoodchamber.org, chamber@vestaviahills.org, rfigh@montgomerychamber.com, chamberinfo@shelbychamber.net, pelhamchamberofcommerce@gmail.com, sandra@leedsareachamber.com,nhewston@mobilechamber.com, jim@westalabamachamber.com
Cc: newhopebirmingham@gmail.com, pastortb@nrschurch.org , gmallisham@bcri.org, onoyemi@fiaal.org, fbcensley@gmail.com, dgreen@mtcfc.org, minister@uucbham.org, officestaff@faithchapel.net, katy@churchofthehighlands.com, ashfaq.taufique@bisweb.org, alabama@momschapterleaders.org, danaellis865@gmail.com
Sent: Sun, Nov 27, 2022 9:15 am
Subject: What have AL business chambers done in 2022 to try to help reduce gun violence?
What have your Alabama chambers of commerce done in 2022 to try to help reduce gun violence in Alabama?
Information you provide will be recorded at https://al6thcongdist-ihaveuntiljan13.blogspot.com/2022/10/pressuring-gov-ivey-for-leadership-on.html
Thank you.
Rob Shattuck
Email to JeffCo Commissioner & Bham Business Alliance CEO-elect Ammons
From: Rob Shattuck <rdshatt@aol.com>
To: ammonss@jccal.org <ammonss@jccal.org>
Cc:clinton.woods@birminghamal.gov, hunter.williams@birminghamal.gov, valerie.abbott@birminghamal.gov, jonathan.moore2@birminghamal.gov, Darrell.OQuinn@birminghamal.gov, crystal.smitherman@birminghamal.gov, wardine.alexander@birminghamal.gov, carol.clarke@birminghamal.gov, latonya.tate@birminghamal.gov, tysons@jccal.org, stephensj@jccal.org, KnightJoe@jccal.org, a, scalesl@jccal.org,; KnightJoe@jccal.org <KnightJoe@jccal.org>; scalesl@jccal.org <scalesl@jccal.org>; nnewhopebirmingham@gmail.com, pastortb@nrschurch.org , gmallisham@bcri.org, onoyemi@fiaal.org, fbcensley@gmail.com, dgreen@mtcfc.org, minister@uucbham.org, officestaff@faithchapel.net, katy@churchofthehighlands.com, ashfaq.taufique@bisweb.org, alabama@momschapterleaders.org, danaellis865@gmail.com dcole@bcatoday.org, ejerkins@birminghambusinessalliance.com, director@homewoodchamber.org, chamber@vestaviahills.org, rfigh@montgomerychamber.com, chamberinfo@shelbychamber.net, pelhamchamberofcommerce@gmail.com, sandra@leedsareachamber.com, paulawilson.al@gmail.com, skirkpatrick.al@gmail.com , melissa.bailey.al@gmail.com, info@phillipensler.com, jvance@law.ua.edu, lcw0045@auburn.edu
Sent: Sun, May 7, 2023 12:14 pm
Subject: May I meet with you to discuss reducing gun violence?
Dear JeffCo Commissioner & Bham Business Alliance CEO-elect Ammons,
I am a constituent of yours.
You are resigning as Jefferson County commissioner to become CEO of the Birmingham Business Alliance.
I have sent you and the Business Alliance numerous emails about guns.
May I meet with you to discuss reducing gun violence?
Thank you.
Rob Shattuck
Mountain Brook
[For filing in https://al6thcongdist-ihaveuntiljan13.blogspot.com/2023/01/our-nightmare-of-failure-re-sensible.html and https://al6thcongdist-ihaveuntiljan13.blogspot.com/2022/12/what-will-reduce-gun-violence.html]

Email to Faith in Action Birmingham Peacemakers and Alabama Moms Demand
From: Rob Shattuck <rdshatt@aol.com>
To: newhopebirmingham@gmail.com <newhopebirmingham@gmail.com>; pastortb@nrschurch.org <pastortb@nrschurch.org>; onoyemi@fiaal.org <onoyemi@fiaal.org>; fbcensley@gmail.com <fbcensley@gmail.com>; dgreen@mtcfc.org <dgreen@mtcfc.org>; officestaff@faithchapel.net <officestaff@faithchapel.net>; katy@churchofthehighlands.com <katy@churchofthehighlands.com>; ashfaq.taufique@bisweb.org <ashfaq.taufique@bisweb.org>; daniel@fiaal.org <daniel@fiaal.org>; Moms Demand Action Alabama <alabama@momschapterleaders.org>; Melissa Bailey <melissa.bailey.al@gmail.com>; Dana Ellis <danaellis865@gmail.com>; Rev. Julie Conrady <minister@uucbham.org>
Sent: Tuesday, August 8, 2023 at 05:35:50 PM CDT
Subject: What will you do to get in Rep Gary Palmer's face about guns
Dear Faith in Action Birmingham Peacemakers and Moms Demand Alabama:
I have emailed you about asking the Montgomery mayoral and city council candidates at WSFA12's August 10th forum (https://www.wsfa.com/2023/08/03/wsfa-12-news-host-montgomery-candidates-forum-aug-10/ ) what the candidates will do to try to reduce gun violence in Montgomery if they win their election. (My email can be found at http://al6thcongdist-ihaveuntiljan13.blogspot.com/2023/08/montgomery-candidates-what-will-you-do.html.)
Last night Rep. Gary Palmer held a meet and greet in Alabaster at the city hall. https://twitter.com/USRepGaryPalmer/status/1688548437313110016.
This morning I tweeted Rep. Palmer, asking what questions were asked of him at his Alabaster meet and greet, and whether any TV reporters showed up and asked him questions. https://twitter.com/RobShattuckAL06/status/1688828236296245248
In 2019, following the El Paso and Dayton mass shootings, ABC3340's Pam Huff interviewed Rep. Palmer about what further gun regulation he supported in order to reduce gun violence. Rep. Palmer basically indicated he will not support any further gun regulation You can watch the interview at https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ie6gbheR72g.
Since 2019 I have tried many times to get more questioning of Rep. Palmer about guns and questioning of others in the Alabama Congressional delegation or running for Congress about guns, all to no avail. See https://twitter.com/search?q=youtu.be%2FIe6gbheR72g%20(from%3Arobshattuckal06)&src=typed_query&f=live.
So my question to you is, will you do anything to help me get in Rep. Palmer's face about his opposition to further gun regulation?
I will add this email to https://al6thcongdist-ihaveuntiljan13.blogspot.com/2022/12/what-will-reduce-gun-violence.html and also add it to https://al6thcongdist-ihaveuntiljan13.blogspot.com/2023/01/how-much-does-gary-palmer-jerk-us-around.html.
Thank you for your attention to this email.
Sincerely,
Rob Shattuck

Thursday, December 8, 2022

Targeting Dale Strong

Tuesday, December 6, 2022

Brady letter to U.S. Senate re assault weapons ban

I. The letter

The Brady United Against Gun Violence organization today published in Roll Call an open letter  signed by 50 healthcare professionals — including surgeons, pediatricians, emergency medicine doctors, and more — imploring the U.S. Senate to save lives by passing an assault weapons ban.  https://www.bradyunited.org/act/thisisourlane#openletter

The text of the letter is as follows:

Dear Senators,

We are trauma surgeons, pediatricians, emergency medicine doctors, and healthcare professionals, and we’re in Washington, D.C., this week meeting with your offices to urge the Senate to bring the Assault Weapons Ban Act to a vote before the end of the current session. This past year, we’ve treated over 110,000 Americans who have been shot. Forty-five thousand of those never made it home. These senseless tragedies are increasing, with gun-related injury becoming the leading cause of death in children and adolescents. Tackling this complex public health problem requires a number of solutions, one of the most important of which is banning assault weapons.

While this measure continues to gather dust in the Senate, the slaughter of Americans with military-style assault rifles has ripped apart families and communities across the country. From a grocery store in Buffalo and an LBGTQ+ nightclub in Colorado Springs to a July 4th parade in Highland Park and an elementary school in Uvalde, the one thing that holds true in all these circumstances is that the best medical treatment is prevention.

Assault weapons are uniquely deadly. Data demonstrates mass-shooting fatalities were 70% less likely to occur under the federal assault weapons ban of 1994. And we have seen this firsthand. These weapons operate with such force they literally blow holes into human bodies. They liquefy organs and explode bones. While we do our best to save lives and treat the destruction caused by military weapons that leave bodies resembling blocks of swiss cheese, it’s not always possible. Sometimes, children’s bodies are left so unrecognizable that parents can only identify them through DNA tests.

While the care we provide to patients is critical, we have both the opportunity and responsibility to think beyond the bedside to advocate for solutions to address this public health crisis. From motor vehicle fatalities and tobacco to clean water and vaccines, healthcare professionals have always been at the forefront of addressing public health problems. We want to make sure our position is clear: Failing to pass an assault weapons ban means more patients on our operating tables and explaining to families that their loved one is never coming home.

We plead with you to bring the Assault Weapons Ban to a vote before the legislative session ends. And we call on all others to join us, Brady, This is Our Lane, and our partner March Fourth by contacting your senators and demanding the Senate pass this life-saving bill without delay.

Signed,

Joseph V. Sakran, MD, MPH, MPA FACS, Brady Board Member and @ThisIsOurLane Founder
Aaron Wolfe, DO
Amy Shriver, MD FAAP
Angela Scott, MD, FAAP
Ashley B. Hink, MD, MPH
Bijan Ketabchi, MD, MPH
Brian Eichner, MD
Brian R. Stork, MD, FACS
Brittany Ebbing, MD, MPH
Cathy White, MD
Christina Colosimo, DO MS
Christopher Turner, MD MPH
Cynthia Carter, DO
Dorothy R. Novick, MD
Dr. Morgan Wurtz
Dr. Vladimirovna Tatiana, DO
Dr. Cassandra Stegall, DO
Dr. Jennifer Gemmill Eileen Broomall, MD
Elliot Lieberman, MD
Emily Lieberman, MD
Habib Khoury, MD
Halleh Akbarnia, MD FACEP
Hannah Boutros-Khoury, M.D.
James McJunkin, MD
Jena Krueger, MD
Jennifer Rubin, MD
Jenny Stevens, MD MPH
Jerrold Eichner, MD
Jordan Vaughn, MD
Kelsey Gastineau, MD FAAP
Kerith E. Spicknall, MD
Kristen Kann, MD
Kristine M. Pleacher, MD
Lindsay D. Clukies, MD
Maya Haasz, MD
Melissa Kelley, MD
Nadja Peter, MD
Nicholas Puoplo, MD
Nicole M. King, MD
Peter T. Masiakos, MD, MS, FACS, FAAP
Rebecca Meyers, MD
Roy Guerrero, MD
Sabah Servaes, MD
Seth Trueger, MD MPH FACEP
Sheena Gupta McKenzie, MD, MBA, FAAP
Sofia Chaudhary, MD
Terence McAllister, MD FAAP
Mary Ottolini, MD
Zachary Beck Domont, MD

II. #GunsForSelfDefenseOnly
Email to Brady United legal team
From: Rob Shattuck <rdshatt@aol.com>To: mstankiewicz@bradyunited.org <mstankiewicz@bradyunited.org>
Sent: Wed, Dec 7, 2022 4:41 am
Subject: For Brady legal team - re letter to U.S. Senate urging assault weapon ban
Dear Brady Legal Team,
I live in Alabama.
To defeat the Second Amendment extremists, I think all advocacy for common sense gun solutions, such as banning assault weapons, should be bolted to the mantra #GunsForSelfDefenseOnly.
I am urging this widely, such as indicated at https://al6thcongdist-ihaveuntiljan13.blogspot.com/2022/11/gunsforselfdefenseonly.html.
I think President Biden, Congress, governors, mayors, state lawmakers, law enforcement officials, and others having public responsibility to prevent gun violence in America should adopt the mantra of #GunsForSelfDefenseOnly and make a public declaration such as set out at https://al6thcongdist-ihaveuntiljan13.blogspot.com/2022/09/declaration-of-public-officials-for-gun.html.
Use of the mantra #GunsForSelfDefenseOnly, and the aforesaid declaration, require that they be defensible under the Second Amendment. In Alabama and elsewhere I have solicited opinion about what the Second Amendment protects and does not protect, but have not gotten response.
The purpose of this email is to urge the Brady Legal Team to consider whether the #GunsForSelfDefenseOnly mantra would be useful, and defensible under the Second Amendment, in connection with the open letter to the United States Senate that Brady United Against Gun Violence published in Roll Call yesterday, signed by 50 healthcare professionals, imploring the U.S. Senate to save lives by passing an assault weapons ban.
As part of my efforts on this, I will post this email at https://al6thcongdist-ihaveuntiljan13.blogspot.com/2022/12/brady-letter-to-us-senate-re-assault.html.
Perhaps the advocacy and messaging that Brady United is doing regarding an assault weapons ban is wholly adequate.
Perhaps this email will be helpful to Brady United.
Thank you for your attention to this email.
Sincerely,
Rob Shattuck
Mountain Brook, AL
-----Original Message-----
From: Rob Shattuck <rdshatt@aol.com>
To: mstankiewicz@bradyunited.org <mstankiewicz@bradyunited.org>
Sent: Tue, Dec 6, 2022 11:29 am
Subject: can you provide me with email address for legal team
Dear Mr. Stankiewicz:
I am not in the media. I would like to send an email to the Brady United legal team. Can you provide me with an appropriate email address? Can I send the email to you, and you forward it to the legal team?
Thanks.
Rob Shattuck

Second email to Brady legal team

From: Rob Shattuck <rdshatt@aol.com>
To: mstankiewicz@bradyunited.org <mstankiewicz@bradyunited.org>
Sent: Tue, Dec 13, 2022 6:51 pm
Subject: For Brady legal team - re letter to U.S. Senate urging assault weapon ban
Dear Brady Legal Team,
This second email to you continues to press for using the mantra #GunsForSelfDefenseOnly to shape common sense gun control legislation that is proposed at this time by gun control advocates, to shape the advocacy that is made on behalf of such proposed legislation, and to shape the defense in the courts of such legislation that is passed by Congress or in the states.
The first email I sent to you is the below December 7th email, which December 7th email I have posted at https://al6thcongdist-ihaveuntiljan13.blogspot.com/2022/12/brady-letter-to-us-senate-re-assault.html.
I will also post this email at https://al6thcongdist-ihaveuntiljan13.blogspot.com/2022/12/brady-letter-to-us-senate-re-assault.html.
Thank you.
Sincerely,
Rob Shattuck
Mountain Brook, AL
[December 7th email is omitted here on this link and is above on this link.]

Third email to Brady legal team
From: Rob Shattuck <rdshatt@aol.com>
To: mstankiewicz@bradyunited.org <mstankiewicz@bradyunited.org>
Sent: Thu, Dec 15, 2022 9:00 am
Subject: For Brady legal team: This week's Rhode Island high capacity gun magazine ban case
Dear Brady Legal Team,
It seems to me that this week's Rhode Island high capacity gun magazine ban case (Judge upholds Rhode Island's high-capacity gun magazine ban. Here's what it means) shows the merits of the mantra of #GunsForSelfDefenseOnly for shaping common sense gun control legislation, shaping the advocacy that is made on behalf of proposed legislation, and shaping the defense in the courts of such legislation.
The below are quoted from the foregoing article and are either exact quotations of what Judge McConnell said in the case or characterize what the Judge said:
"Consistent with its obligation to protect public safety, but consonant with its fealty to the Constitution, the Rhode Island General Assembly has responded with, among other firearms regulations, the [large capacity magazine] Ban."
The Second Amendment protects the right to people to "keep and bear arms," and at its core the right to self-defense, McConnell observed.
The ban was a reasonable and measured approach to restricting large-capacity magazines, which in practice easily convert handguns into semi-automatic weapons capable of rapid fire, he said.
He accepted the opinion of an expert for the state that throughout history "high capacity firearms ... were understood to be weapons of war or anti-insurrection, not weapons of individual self defense."
Where the Judge refers to "fealty to the Constitution," the touchstone for that is that SCOTUS has pronounced that there is a constitutional right of individuals to own and carry guns in public for self-defense.
That right does not exist in a vacuum, and there is also a governmental "obligation to protect public safety."
It seems to me those two things (the "right to self-defense" and "protect[ing] public safety") frame and will frame just about every gun control case.
I think the public can understand those two things (the "right to self-defense" and "protect[ing] public safety"), and the public understanding those two things will allow the public to better evaluate what they hear from the two sides about gun control cases.
To contribute to that happening, the public needs to hear parties who are in the public eye (or who get into the public eye) talking about the "right to self-defense" and "protect[ing] public safety".
I urge that the messaging by the Brady organization be as much as possible about the "right to self-defense" and "protect[ing] public safety".
Thank you for your attention to this email.
Sincerely,
Rob Shattuck
Mountain Brook, AL