Wednesday, January 21, 2015

Dysfunctional Congress, or no?

The State of the Union address has been delivered. Below are responses of Senator Sessions, Senator Shelby, and Representative Sewell. [I will post response of Representative Palmer when I can find it.]

Do the SOTU address and these responses help you in deciding whether we will have a dysfunctional Congress for another two years?


AL lawmakers respond to State of the Union address

Posted: Jan 20, 2015 9:32 PM CSTUpdated: Jan 20, 2015 9:33 PM CST
By WAFF.com Staff
CONNECT

From Senator Jeff Sessions:

“Tonight President Obama stayed the course of tax, spend, borrow, regulate, and add to the debt. This policy has hammered working families, whose average inflation-adjusted income has fallen a stunning $4,200 since 2009. Labor force participation for both men and women between 25–54 has been steadily falling since the President took office, while 12 million people have left the workforce entirely.
On immigration, the President remains wedded to a lawless policy that serves only the interest of an international elite while reducing jobs and benefits for everyday Americans. All net employment gains since the recession in 2007 have gone to foreign workers, and yet the President has violated federal law in order to provide work permits to 5 million illegal immigrants—allowing them to take any of the few good jobs that exist. In effect, the President delivered an address tonight to a Congress whose authority he does not recognize and to a public whose votes he has nullified with an imperial edict. Congress must use every tool at its disposal to stop this unlawful edict, end the immigration lawlessness, and reverse our slide towards congressional irrelevance.”


From Senator Richard Shelby:

“Tonight's address from President Obama was once again heavy on rhetoric and light on real solutions for families and businesses across the nation. Voters sent a strong message in November that they are dissatisfied with the growing role of government in their lives, yet the President failed to discuss his plans to work with Republicans in Congress on addressing these important concerns.

“The President's address tonight did not include plans to rescind his decision to circumvent Congress and unilaterally grant amnesty to millions of illegal immigrants. It failed to outline a way to provide the American people with relief from the destructive impacts of Obamacare. We also did not hear about his plans to enact policies that will reenergize the private sector and encourage job growth or to work with Republicans on common sense ideas to boost our nation's energy independence such as allowing construction of the Keystone XL Pipeline.

“I believe that Alabamians – and all Americans – deserve better than more of the same failed tax and spend policies from this Administration. That is why I urge President Obama to join us in supporting policies that get Washington out of the way and create economic conditions to give the American people an opportunity to succeed.”

STATEMENT FROM CONGRESSWOMAN SEWELL ON THE STATE OF THE UNION
January 21, 2015

Washington, D.C. – Congresswoman Terri Sewell (D-AL) released the following statement on President Obama’s State of the Union Address:

Our nation’s greatness rests firmly on the pledge that all Americans have an equal opportunity to achieve their dreams. Tonight, President Obama proposed turning that pledge into a promise.

The President unveiled his vision to strengthen the working and middle classes by making homeownership more affordable, advocating for paid family leave, and ensuring a college education is more accessible for qualified students.

Our economy has grown tremendously since the depths of the financial crisis. The President reminded us that businesses have created 11 million new jobs and that the unemployment rate has fallen.

We have come far, but that does not mean our work is done. Far too many Americans are still struggling, and we need a comprehensive strategy that adequately addresses their needs.

The President also acknowledged that one of our most fundamental rights – the right to vote – has been ‘denied for too many,’ and referenced the 50th anniversary of the march from Selma to Montgomery.

As a daughter of Selma – and as the Congresswoman who represents Birmingham, Selma, and Montgomery – I know that the injustices protesters suffered on the Edmund Pettus Bridge on Bloody Sunday have not been fully vindicated.

My special guest for the President’s address was 103-year-old voting rights matriarch Amelia Boynton Robinson. Ms. Boynton Robinson was one of those courageous Foot Soldiers who dared to challenge an unfair and unjust system that kept African Americans from exercising their constitutionally protected right to vote.

I am pleased that she had a chance to meet the President tonight, and we look forward to welcoming him to Selma for the 50th commemoration of the historic Selma to Montgomery march.



Letter to Birmingham Business Journal


Birmingham Business Journal
2140 11th Avenue S., Suite 205
Birmingham, AL 35205

Dear Sir,

I am continuing to write in follow up to my July 18, 2014 email to you, which email can be found online here.

In that email, I quoted your editorial "Congressional Inaction Could Derail Recovery" from the "Viewpoint" page in the Business Journal's June 20, 2014 issue (page 19). In the editorial, you said, among other things:

Even the ongoing recovery is threatened by the fierce political divide that has taken hold in our nation....
As has often been the case lately, the primary culprit is Congress . . ..
The petty disputes in Washington must stop. Business leaders need to take an active role by supporting candidates who won't fall into the red vs. blue and Democrat vs. Republican debates.

That was six months ago. 

I am interested in what the Business Journal's thinking is currently, 

The 2014 elections have come and gone, and the Republicans have taken over the Senate and increased their majority in the House of Representatives. 

Have the concerns you expressed in June evaporated? Are you in a "wait and see" mode to determine whether you should continue to have your concerns?

I am continuing my campaign that Congress is broken and cannot do its job properly for the American people. My contention is that the broken condition is connected to our system of campaign finance. (If you have not read it, you should read Harvard Law Professor Lawrence Lessig's short book Lesterland: The Corruption of Congress And How To End It.)

I have no information about whether the Birmingham Business Alliance has given any consideration to my communications to them (including most recently this November 26, 2014 email and this January 9, 2015 letter).

Congressman Palmer remains steadfastly silent to my knowledge. 

He has choices of things he could say, such as "there is nothing wrong with our system of campaign finance that warrants my attention and there is nothing my constituents should concern themselves about" or "there are things which call for my attentions as the Representative of the 6th district, and here is what I am urging (Congressman Palmer is supporting term limits I believe, and he could say, for example, that action about term limits is all that is needed)".

But Congressman Palmer won't say anything, to my knowledge.

Retired Congressman Bachus spent twenty years in Washington, and one would think he would have some informed views on this matter. I have no idea whether retired Congressman Bachus is willing to share his thoughts with the Business Journal, but you could ask him.

In all events, I am interested in what the Birmingham Business Journal thinks.

Thank you.

Sincerely,
Rob Shattuck

Monday, January 19, 2015

Case study, second installment

Last Tuesday, I started this Case study of political leadership failure.  Below is an email I received from Democrats. I project that our political leadership in Washington will fail us on this. What do you think? What does Congressman Palmer think? You could ask him. (He hasn't answered anything I've asked him, so there is no point in my asking him.)



From: democrats@thehousemajoritypac.com
To: rdshatt@aol.com
Sent: 1/18/2015 5:01:13 P.M. Central Standard Time
Subj: SIGN: protect Social Security 

Robert:

The GOP's first priority of the new Congress is clear -- they want to cut Social Security.

We have to fight back. They backtracked on promises to create jobs, and instead, decided to gut a program that millions of people rely on. Don’t allow them to destroy all that we have worked so hard for.

So many of you have already stood up, and we're so thankful for that. But now, will you demand that they leave Social Security alone by adding your name here?

Boehner and his allies said they'd be focused on job creation, but if that was true, they wouldn't make attacking Social Security their first priority. It's plain old dirty politics -- and it only hurts the most vulnerable working Americans. We won't stand for it, and we need your help to stop them, Robert.

Add your name here to demand that the GOP stop their senseless attacks on Social Security.

Thanks for helping us hold the GOP accountable.

Stop the Tea Party

http://action.thehousemajoritypac.com/page/m/31af503d/244ae26a/13054e99/710676a6/119162813/VEsF/

Tuesday, January 13, 2015

Case study of political leadership failure

Yesterday, The Hill published this article "Dems warn of Social Security cuts".

Dems warn of Social Security cuts

By Alexander Bolton - 01/12/15 11:59 AM EST
Democrats are pressing Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell (R-Ky.) to repudiate a rules change by House Republicans that could cut Social Security disability payments by 20 percent.
House Republicans last week included language in their new rules for the 114th Congress making it more difficult to allocate payroll tax revenues to replenish the Social Security Disability Trust Fund, which is due to run out of money in 2016.
Democrats are pressing Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell (R-Ky.) to repudiate a rules change by House Republicans that could cut Social Security disability payments by 20 percent.
House Republicans last week included language in their new rules for the 114th Congress making it more difficult to allocate payroll tax revenues to replenish the Social Security Disability Trust Fund, which is due to run out of money in 2016.
“We are deeply concerned that the rule change in the House will impact millions of Social Security beneficiaries,” Democratic leaders and liberals wrote in a letter sent Monday to McConnell.
They warned that nearly 11 million Americans could see their benefits cut if Congress does not take action in the next two years.
“House Republicans acted according to their extreme ideology and put these benefits at risk by adopting a legislative rule change that creates a point of order against simple bipartisan technical corrections,” they wrote.
They noted that Congress has reallocated taxes between the Social Security retirement and trust funds 11 times in the past.
It last did so in 1994 without facing any significant opposition from Democrats or Republicans.
The trust funds were rebalanced four times under President Reagan, the Democrats noted.
“It is cynical to try and pit retirees and beneficiaries with disabilities against each other, as the House Republican rule change attempts to do,” they wrote.
Senate Democratic Whip Dick Durbin (Ill.), Democratic Policy Committee Chairman Chuck Schumer (N.Y.) and Finance Committee ranking Democrat Ron Wyden (Ore.) signed the letter.
Other signatories included Democratic Sens. Patty Murray (Wash.), Sherrod Brown (Ohio), Debbie Stabenow (Mich.), and Bernie Sanders (Vt.), a liberal independent weighing a presidential bid.
“Holding hostage the Social Security benefits of any American, particularly those of the 9 million Americans with disabilities who are at risk in the coming years, is an untenable proposition,” they wrote. “It only increases the chances of yet another unnecessary manufactured crisis, akin to shutting down the government or threatening the full faith and credit of the United States.”

[case study to be continued]

Friday, January 9, 2015

More on Congress failing small business

Mr. Victor Brown
Vice President, Minority Business and Small Business Development
Birmingham Business Alliance
Birmingham, AL

Dear Mr. Brown,

I am writing in follow up to my November 26th email to you, which email I posted at this link: Small business and money in politics.

I wish to call to the attention of the small business community the Wall Street Journal op/ed piece on December 26th  entitled "How Congress Bribes States to Give Up Power", by former United States Senator James Buckley.

This op/ed piece is reproduced below and deserves a full read by you. The op/ed piece says a lot about what I think is wrong with Congress and with our Federal government which Congress oversees.

Here are some questions that I think the op/ed piece should raise for your small business constituents:

First, what does the op/ed piece signify about the kind of environment that Congress creates for the conduct of small business in the United States.

I would particularly ask your small business constituents to think about how impaired and diverted Congress is in doing a "decent" job in what it legislates, such impairment and diversion resulting from lawmakers being dedicated to serving whatever will get and keep campaign contributions flowing to them that are needed for the lawmakers to win elections and stay in office.

Many donors get rewarded by the lawmakers for the campaign contributions the donors make, but at what cost and consequence for everyone else?

The op/ed piece does an excellent job of describing some of the cost and consequence.

After your small business constituents make their own determinations about that, those who agree things are wrong with Congress and the Federal government which Congress oversees, should next ask, "Can anything be done about this?"

On this question, note particularly the op/ed piece's reference to "the newly elected members of Congress becom[ing] contaminated by the prevailing congressional culture," and the warning:
Congressional freshmen should be warned, however, that if they accept this suggestion [for reform] they will be fiercely opposed by their senior colleagues who have found the creation and exploitation of lucrative grants-in-aid programs the surest way to scratch their constituents’ backs (think “entitlements”) and ensure their re-election.
Would you care to apply the preceding to Alabama 6th Congressional district's freshman Congressman Gary Palmer?

I have been applying the same for months to Mr. Palmer, and it has not been a pretty picture. See, e.g., what I said in July about Why Gary Palmer will be ineffective.

In short, on the question of "can anything be done about this," your small business constituents could be well justified in concluding, "no, we are stuck with a Congress that is a failure for us."

I hope you will pass this letter along to your small business constituents. I expect to be communicating with some of them directly about this.

Thank you very much.

Sincerely,
Rob Shattuck




How Congress Bribes States to Give Up Power

It’s time to end the more than 1,100 grants-in-aid programs that spend one-sixth of the federal budget.


Before the newly elected members of Congress become contaminated by the prevailing congressional culture, they should consider a reform that would achieve a broader range of benefits than any other they might embrace: dismantling the more than 1,100 grants-in-aid programs that spend one-sixth of the federal budget on matters that are the exclusive business of state and local governments.
Congressional freshmen should be warned, however, that if they accept this suggestion they will be fiercely opposed by their senior colleagues who have found the creation and exploitation of lucrative grants-in-aid programs the surest way to scratch their constituents’ backs (think “entitlements”) and ensure their re-election. But that should add zest to the enterprise.
ENLARGE
GETTY IMAGES
Those programs, which provide funding for Medicaid as well as everything from road and bridge construction to rural housing, job training and fighting childhood obesity—now touch virtually every activity in which state and local governments are engaged. Their direct cost has grown, according to the federal budget, to an estimated $640.8 billion in 2015 from $24.1 billion in 1970.
Their indirect costs, however, go far beyond those numbers both in terms of dollars wasted and the profound distortions they have brought about in how we govern ourselves. Because the grants come with detailed federal directives, they deprive state and local officials of the flexibility to meet their own responsibilities in the most effective ways, and undermine their citizens’ ability to ensure that their taxes will be used to meet their priorities rather than those of distant federal regulators. The irony is that the money the states and local governments receive from Washington is derived either from federal taxes paid by residents of the states or from the sale of bonds that their children will have to redeem.
Congress finds the authority to enact those programs in the Supreme Court’s interpretation of the Constitution’s general-welfare clause in Steward Machine Co. v. Davis (1937). More recently, in the court’s 2012 NFIB v. Sebelius decision upholding the Affordable Care Act’s individual mandate, Chief Justice John Roberts wrote that Congress may use federal funds to “induce the States to adopt policies that the Federal Government itself could not impose,” so long as participation by the states is voluntary. To put it another way, Congress is licensed to dabble in areas in which it is forbidden to act, which it does by bribing the states to adopt Congress’s approaches to problems that are the states’ exclusive responsibility.
It is impossible, in this article, to detail all the costs imposed by those programs, but here are some of the most egregious ones: They add layers of federal and state administrative expenses to the cost of the subsidized projects; distort state priorities by offering lucrative grants for purposes of often trivial importance; and undermine accountability because state officials bound by federal regulations can’t be held responsible for the costs and failures of the projects they administer.
Finally, and of prime importance, those programs have subverted the Constitution’s federalism, its division of federal and state responsibilities, that was intended to prevent a concentration of power in a central government that could threaten individual liberties.
The states are free to decline to participate in the programs, but that has proved very hard to do. Money from Washington is still regarded as “free,” and state officials are delighted to accept grants, strings and all, rather than raise the extra money that would be required to pay the full cost of the projects they freely undertake with federal subsidies. What makes declining grants particularly difficult is the fact that if a state does not participate in a program, its share of the money—derived in whole or part from its own taxpayers—will go elsewhere.
There is only one way to resolve the problems that have resulted from Congress’s addiction to grants-in-aid programs, and that is to terminate all of them. They must all go because none is free of the added costs described above. If any exception is made, members of Congress will be encouraged to launch a new wave of grants on the assurance that theirs will be exempt from the problems and costs that have plagued the existing ones, and it would take another generation to prove them wrong.
Yet because federal transfers now constitute about 30% of the states’ revenues, Congress cannot cut off the funds overnight. Therefore, it should terminate the programs by converting all the grants the states and localities are currently relying on into single, no-strings-attached block grants, one for each state, that would be phased out over six years. That would allow Congress and the states the time to adjust their respective tax codes to accommodate the successive reductions in the federal transfers.
If the newcomers to Congress embrace the reform, the timing could not be more propitious. Recent stories concerning the incompetence, and worse, at the IRS, the Veterans Health Administration, the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, and other federal agencies have undermined the myth that Washington necessarily knows best. Once Americans have learned the true cost of those programs, they will know they have everything to gain from their termination both as citizens and taxpayers.
Mr. Buckley is a retired federal appellate judge and a former U.S. senator. He is the author of “Saving Congress From Itself” (Encounter Books, 2014).

Thursday, January 1, 2015

Where's Congressman Bachus' exit interview?

In last year's Republican primary race in the Alabama 6th Congressional district, I asked retiring Congressman Bachus whether the voters and the candidates should be concerned about a broken and dysfunctional Congress.

Congressman Bachus wrote me back to the effect that it was his policy, in connection with a primary campaign, to leave to the candidates discussion of the questions I was asking. See Representative Bachus' response.

I thought Congressman Bachus (and others in the Alabama legislative delegation in Washington) were likely the best informed to provide helpful answers to my questions.

Regrettably, none of the 6th Congressional district candidates were willing to discuss my questions for the benefit of the voters, and now Representative-elect Palmer continues unwilling to discuss my questions for the benefit of his constituents to be. See Just answer the question, Gary Palmer.

What does retiring Congressman Bachus think now? He has served for twenty years as the Representative for the 6th Congressional district. Does he not owe it to the voters to say something to them about whether or not he thinks Congress is broken and dysfunctional,  and, if he does, to offer his suggestions and recommendations for what the voters should do about the situation?